Kelly points out in his answer, there is no single version of events that can be ascribed to all the people who consider themselves or are considered by others to be truthers. The film 911 in plane site and the web site claim that no such object is found on a stock boeing 767. As for the jets, theres no telling how long that could take. Obtaining 30 hours of neverbeforereleased tapes from the. Dick cheney was in command of norad on 911 while running war games. According to the us air force website, f15s can go from scramble order to 29,000 feet in only 2. Debunking 911 conspiracy debunkers with stewart bradley. Some truthers believe the planes that hit the world trade center and pentagon on 911 were not commercial airliners at all. Debunking 911 conspiracy theories accredited times.
Senate in october 2001 and for two years it stood as the official account. Jul 30, 2017 norad exercise manager ken merchant added that the nmcc, located at the pentagon, regularly participated in norad exercises by interjecting emergency action messages eams. Debunking the real 911 myths why popular mechanics cant face up to reality. Norad standdown the prevention of interceptions of the commandeered planes it is standard operating procedure sop to scramble jet fighters whenever a jetliner goes off course or radio contact with it is lost. I ask that people not post books that address the other side of the argument. We do know that norad fighters were on 15minute alert prior to 911, but even now it might be around 8 minutes. The 911 commission told us that norad scrambled fighters from otis and langley air force bases on 911. For those of you who dont know, a truther is a person affiliated with the 911 truth movement, who rejects the official explanation provided for the 911 attacks and instead claims that a us. Popular 9 11 conspiracy theories books showing 15 of 5 dreaming war. Norad has also increased its fighter coverage and has installed radar to. A lot of people seem to have misconceptions about what norad is and what they do.
The jet fighters at norads disposal could respond very quickly. For one thing, the tapes contradict many previous accounts, by many different officials, including people in both the faa and the military. It is the fourth part of this work which is the most crucial for those opposed to the official theory, for it involves countering the most widely publicized 911 debunking account. The terrorist attacks of september 11, 2001 changed the world forever and generated a lot of conspiracy theories. The 911 conspiracy theories started out mostly in the political left but have broadened into what new york magazine describes as terra incognita where left and right meet, fusing sixties countercultural distrust with the donttreadonme variety. In 2005, pm addressed these claims in our first report debunking 911 conspiracy theories, which was later expanded into a book that was updated in 2011. Daniele ganser, have pointed out that the 911 commission report, which was supposed to deliver a complete description of all the events occurring on that day, omitted the news that wtc 7 collapsed a few hours later due to fire. Ive heard him make a speech, though, and he has a vice thats always very well worth noticing because its always a bad sign. The truth about 911 books about the 911 hoax and coverup and the truth movement.
Bush hesitated for 441 days before starting the 911 commission. Stand down exposing norads wag the 911 window dressing tale. Gore vidal shelved 1 time as 911conspiracytheories avg rating 3. Every bit the socratic analyzer, he rips to shreds the web of lies, falsities and deceptions spun by popular mechanics to create the illusion it had debunked conspiracy theories about who did 911. Six really stupid 911 conspiracies debunked in about six. Sep 11, 2007 six years later, and its still hard to believe it was real. Prior to 911 they spent most of their resources looking at external threats, as their original purpose was to monitor potential incoming ballistic missiles from the former soviet union. Why conspiracy theories cant stand up to the facts kindle edition by popular mechanics, david dunbar, brad reagan, james b. Theorists believe that the world trade center buildings were demolished by bombs, phone calls from the planes were made up, or that former president george w. Jun 29, 2015 norad and cheyenne mountain afs images of modern america lihani dafc, j. Also at the time, there were only 14 jets on alert in seven cities in the continental united states. On the anniversary of the september 11 terror attacks, conspiracy theories about that fateful date in american history have more than persisted. I just want to say that the citation needed is for whether or not the 911 commission actually says that above statement. Oct 10, 2006 but 2 more conspiracy theories were pretty well debunked recently.
Jan 12, 20 the bottom line is that norad officials working for ralph eberhart covered up the facts about the lack of air defense on 911 by lying to the american people and by failure to cooperate with the 911 investigations. This is a collation of the multiple parts of an extensive report by 911 researcher adam taylor that exposes the fallacies and flaws in the arguments made by the editors of popular mechanics pm in the latest edition of debunking 911 myths. On 911, the performance of the nmcc, which plays a critical role in establishing the military chain of command and communicating orders, was remarkably poor. The contents of this article are similar to what griffin says about the norad tapes in debunking 911 debunking. United states government operations and exercises on. Although there is an official version of the attacks on the twin towers and the pentagon, parallel theories continue to circulate on the web to this day. The popularity of the 911 conspiracy theory would continue to ebb and flow after each of these reports. Stand down exposing norad s wag the 911 window dressing tale. America seemingly had the most powerful air force in the world but failed to intercept any of the planes that day, which theorists believe is an indication of a government conspiracy to. In response to david ray griffin, published the following and quotes the real purveyor of 911 myths, james meigs of popular mechanics.
Top 5 911 truther myths you should be prepared to debunk. Nov 20, 2007 debunking every single 911 conspiracy theory, one at a time. Debunking every single 911 conspiracy theory, one at a time. However, if you work from the opposite direction by taking the alleged group and asking if the event is the best way to fulfil their aims, the answer is almost always no. Could it have shot down united 93, as conspiracy theorists claim. Johnmichael talboo jmtq so stewart, lets jump right into our shared passion of debunking the socalled 911 debunkers shall we. Jul 05, 2015 however, if you work from the opposite direction by taking the alleged group and asking if the event is the best way to fulfil their aims, the answer is almost always no. Heres what david ray griffin presents in his book debunking 911 debunking. Listen to article over 15 years after the tragic 911 attacks and conspiracy theories still abound in the darkest corners of the internet as to what happened on that day.
The technique employed by mainstream news sources in regard to recent worldwide attention given to 911 ips the directors cut has become predictable and expected. The case against ralph eberhart, norads 911 commander dig. Jul 06, 2016 general ralph eberhart, who was commander of norad on 911, reiterated the timeline in testimony to the u. Most people believe 911 was deliberately orchestrated by osama bin laden. The bottom line is that norad officials working for ralph eberhart covered up the facts about the lack of air defense on 911 by lying to the american people and by failure to cooperate with the 911 investigations. Books about the 911 hoax and coverup and the truth movement. Thats how you debunk most conspiracy theories, simply reverse the process and work from plan to event, rather than event to plan. Debunking the debunkers by dave vonkleist 911 in plane.
But since the moment the attacks happened, others have insisted it was all a setup designed to increase american and israeli military power. Blood for oil and the cheneybush junta paperback by. Norad deliberately ordered their fighter jets to stand down and allow the hijacked planes to reach their targets. Skeptic project is a web site dedicated to investigating the internets most common conspiracy theories, hoaxes, and so on. Debunking 911 conspiracy theories the libertarian republic. Sep 11, 2019 the 11 most compelling 911 conspiracy theories purported theories about what really happened on september 11 are apparently still up for debate. This is an excellent book for those appealing to reason and logic to explain the issues surrounding the socalled. What is the best evidence that debunks the 911 truthers. But 2 more conspiracy theories were pretty well debunked recently. September 11 is a day marked by tragedy since the terrorist attacks of 911 in 2001.
So if you tend to lean on the side of the conspiracy youre not going to believe the 911 commission, and if you lean the opposite way then you will will be more inclined to. Pre911, flights originating in the states were not seen as threats and norad wasnt prepared to track them, said the magazine. Myers reported that the north american aerospace defense command norad had practiced five exercise hijack events between november 1999 and october 2000, all of which included a suicide. A sceptical look at claims made by truther protestors at ground zero in september 2012 from the viewpoint of a chemist. Military and norad had also planned to conduct several military exercises and a drill was being held by the national reconnaissance office, a department of defense agency. How believers in the 911 conspiracy theory respond to.
Air force general richard myers responded to a pointed question on the subject of military exercises, or war games, practiced prior to september 11th 2001. But debunkers will protest that the norad audio tapes prove the official story, no matter how implausible. The technique employed by mainstream news sources in regard to recent worldwide attention given to 911 ips. Nov 29, 2008 debunking the 911 debunkers with stewart bradley.
Norad and cheyenne mountain afs images of modern america lihani dafc, j. Its difficult to pinpoint a precise moment when the popularity of the 911 conspiracy theory peaked, though it was probably sometime in 2006. Eberhart added that norad was notified about the hijacked flight 77 coming into washington at 9. However, some 911 researchers have mustered even more arguments that they say cast serious doubt on the flight 175 notification time. The question is difficult to answer because, as mr. Popular mechanics debunked this theory and explained that before 911, the north american air defense command norad looked outward for threats. Sep 11, 20 false rumors still persist in 911 truth conspiracy theories surrounding the events of 911 continue today, more than a decade after the event. Between september 2000 and june 2001, interceptors were scrambled 67 times. The norad timeline had served as the official account of the military response, and elements of that timeline appeared in the book air war over america notably information concerning united flight 93, e. Seventeen years have passed, but conspiracy hypotheses are still circulating on the. There are many conspiracy theories that attribute the planning and execution of the september 11 attacks against the united states to parties other than, or in.
Of course the orders still stand, have you heard anything to the contrary. September 11th as it unfolds faa and norad tapes youtube. Many 911 conspiracy theories surfaced shortly after the september 11th attacks some bringing compelling arguments, and some not holding up at all. Theres significant support for the 911 commissions timeline from 911 records, then. You have put together some great videos on the subject including, 911 debunking for dummies, 911 cheney connection, as well as putting out, 911. Six really stupid 911 conspiracies debunked in about six seconds. But after copping emails all day from 911 conspiracy nutters, we just had to. Aug 26, 2019 the terrorist attacks of september 11, 2001 changed the world forever and generated a lot of conspiracy theories.
Reporting structure, northeast air defense sector p. Here is a list of 24 facts that cannot be debunked about 911. Elsis, january 8, 2003 in the beginning of a change, the patriot is a scarce and brave man, hated and scorned. The 11 most compelling 911 conspiracy theories purported theories about what really happened on september 11 are apparently still up for debate. False rumors still persist in 911 truth conspiracy theories surrounding the events of 911 continue today, more than a decade after the event. Professor david ray griffin wrote these books late in his career, but his mind is razorsharp. An answer to popular mechanics and other defenders of the official conspiracy theory david ray griffin on. On the morning of september 11th, 2001, four attacks were committed by the islamic terrorist group alqaeda, causing the collapse of the twin towers in new york city, damaging the pentagon in washington, d. The northeast air defense sector neads, where nasypany had been stationed since 1994, is the regional headquarters for the north american. For those reasons alone, eberharts performance that day and the related statements should be thoroughly investigated. The 911 commission report didnt mention the collapse of wtc 7. Sep 10, 2019 the film 911 in plane site and the web site claim that no such object is found on a stock boeing 767.
Norad and cheyenne mountain afs images of modern america. Military and norad had also planned to conduct several military exercises and a drill was being held by the national reconnaissance office, a. Six years later, and its still hard to believe it was real. So, i try to return to your website regularly to get realigned with reality. I think its implausible to believe that 19 people, most of whom didnt. Never forget the lies about air defense failures on 911.
I can see why people find him hugo chavez charming. Griffins main point is that the tapes themselves are suspect. A community for those seeking the real truth behind the 911 attacks, and wish to achieve it by examining the evidence presented by both sides without bias. Despite the fact that countless experts, from senior government officials to respected journalists have thoroughly debunked each and every one of these ludicrous conspiracy. Giant airplanes slamming into the sides of highrise office buildings at 500 mph, leaving vaguely wingshaped gashes behind. And what about other physical evidence that debunks the interception theory, specifically the norad tapes, which document the chaos and. David ray griffin responded with his own book, debunking 911. The case against ralph eberhart, norads 911 commander. The most compelling 911 conspiracy theories newsone. But i often start to believe the conspiritorial bs about 911, gmos, etc. If we put all this together, it is a considerable amount of time, making the 10 minute intercept time impossible. Sep 07, 2011 its difficult to pinpoint a precise moment when the popularity of the 911 conspiracy theory peaked, though it was probably sometime in 2006. How to debunk most conspiracy theories whistling in the wind. On september 11, 2001, the north american aerospace defense command norad was involved in an ongoing operation which involved deploying fighter aircraft to northwestern north america.
1250 334 219 396 1462 363 957 1649 1161 905 1081 159 1418 1152 660 79 1194 403 943 48 615 248 436 1256 1535 1600 1162 9 926 738 646 1209 1402 91 863 814